Sherlock - Lara Pulver and Benedict Cumberbatch and Rebecca Eaton
Sherlock - Actress Lara Pulverand, series executive producer Rebecca Eaton with actor Benedict Cumberbatch (via satellite) discuss the second season during the PBS session at the TCA Winter Press Tour in Pasadena, CA on Thursday, January 5, 2012 © 2011 PBS, Photo by Rahoul Ghose
Sherlock - Lara Pulver and Benedict Cumberbatch and Rebecca Eaton
Actress Lara Pulverand, series executive producer Rebecca Eaton with actor Benedict Cumberbatch (via satellite) at the TCA Winter Press Tour in Pasadena, CA on Thursday, January 5, 2012 © 2011 PBS, Photo by Rahoul Ghose

With the extraordinary success in England and the US of Sherlock, the 21st century version of Sherlock Holmes by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, it was inevitable that a second series would be produced. Sherlock II is currently playing in England and will premiere here in the States this Spring.

Benedict Cumberbatch reprises his role of the great detective, with Martin Freeman once again portraying his friend and colleague Dr James Watson. This season introduces the character of Irene Adler, played by Laura Pulver, the only woman ever to interest Sherlock Holmes.

The new series was spotlighted at the TV Critics tour, with Benedict Cumberbatch doing his interview via satellite from England, as he was there for the premiere of his new movie, War Horse.

What is it like to play the smartest man on TV?

Sherlock 1.01 - Benedict Cumberbatch
Episode 1.01 A Study in Pink – Sherlock Holmes (Benedict Cumberbatch) © BBC

It’s a thrill to get a script as intelligent and as smart as Steven’s are. It’s a rare challenge, for an audience and for an actor, to take part in something with this level of intelligence and wit. And you have to play with it. You have to really enjoy it. It is hard.

It’s a sort of form of mental and physical gymnastics. It’s hard literally sometimes in the cold of winter on the first series and in the heat of summer on the second, to actually get the words out without beads of sweat dripping down or your jaw freezing in a kind of  grin of cold Englishness.

It takes a lot of effort to play clever. It takes very little effort to look clever, as I found out through my character for some reason. And it’s the sort of challenge that you just run [with], and I absolutely love every minute of it as hard as it can be.

It’s a thrill to bring something to an audience that isn’t patronizing as well. To be received with so much love, it’s a validation [from] the audience. It’s something that rewards repeat review, and I think that’s a good thing for it.

Can you talk about the outrage that happened this week in Britain with the nude scene in the show?

Sherlock - Lara Pulver, Benedict Cumberbatch and Rebecca Eaton
Actors Lara Pulver and Benedict Cumberbatch (via satellite) and series executive producer Rebecca Eaton discuss the second season © 2011 PBS, Photo by Rahoul Ghose

Laura was amazing. It takes a hell of a lot of courage to do what she did. There’s nothing that’s supposed to be at all sensational about it. It’s supposed to have an effect on Sherlock.

It’s not supposed to be a source of stimulation for the audience. It’s supposed to throw his radar off, which is exactly what it does.

It’s used as a device of character to create a situation of control, and it’s very much at the heart of their relationship, the power play between the sexes and Holmes and Miss Adler. But an overall answer to the question is, it’s great publicity, isn’t it?

If anyone wants to create a storm in a teacup over it and sell papers the size of telephone directories with hot-air arguments of any description, they’ve really been scraping the barrel this year, so it’s been a lot of fun to watch it come out and laugh them off.

I think there’s an awful lot of support for the way that we did it and the taste that we did it with, and if it creates more interest for the program, thank you very much for that.

What is the relationship between Holmes and Irene Adler?

I think he meets a like-mind. That’s the fundamental attraction for him. He meets someone who is a challenge, who is rather good, and it takes him by surprise, not because he’s a misogynist, not because he views women as any lesser of a species.

He views them as an equal. It’s just that pretty much all people apart from him are a bit stupid.

So the fact that he meets somebody who is a worthy opponent of either sex is of great intrigue. Look at the relationship with Moriarty. There’s a huge bond between those two.

It’s an obsession, but with Ms Adler, it comes with the whole game of love and relationships and the understanding between one sex and another.

Your star has risen so rapidly in this country, due to the Sherlock character. What do you feel about the stardom you’re experiencing now?

War Horse - Benedict Cumberbatch, Patrick Kennedy and Tom Hiddleston
Major Stewart (Benedict Cumberbatch), Lieutenant Waverly (Patrick Kennedy) and Captain Nichols (Tom Hiddleston) © 2011 DreamWorks II Distribution, Photo by David Appleby

Well, you get quite giddy. It’s very flattering. It’s very important to remember that whatever scale you’re working at, it is a job. You have to do your job well, and so you can’t get carried away by too much of it.

I know it’s quite a sober English response. You just treat each job as they come. I’ve been working for nearly 10 years. I got started quite late in my 20s compared to an awful lot of people who are further ahead of me who are younger.

I feel very fortunate and very blessed, but it happened very gradually, but the last bit of it, the trip into being far more on the radar has been very sudden.

You’ve just been anointed for the new Star Trek movie, can you talk about that? What will you play?

(He smiles and looks over to his right side at an invisible person) ‘What’s that? Sorry? I can’t say anything?’ Sorry, there’s a lawyer standing here saying I can’t say anything! (he laughs)

I’m hugely, hugely excited, and I’m very flattered. I like this anointing thing. It’s Biblical! I jumped around an awful lot at 1:00 in the morning, whenever I found out that I’d been given a part in it.

Obviously I’m not here to talk about that, and I will do in the future, I’m sure, but I’m just getting my head around the fact that it’s happened. I’ll just give you my headline on it, which is I’m over the moon.

Judy Sloane

Judy is Film Review Online's regular Los Angeles based reporter.

2 replies on “Sherlock, Season 2 – Benedict Cumberbatch on Holmes and soon to be Star Trek baddie”

  1. Benedict Cumberbatch has a reputation for playing odd, brilliant men extremely well. His Holmes is cold, technophilic and emotionally unreadable. Hyperkinetic and elliptical of mind and body, Sherlock solves tortuous crimes with the effortless ease that leaves a breathless audience mystified in his slipstream.

    Sherlock is so many steps ahead of the audience that Martin Freeman’s Dr Watson is left to patiently explain last-minute revelations and sinuous plot twists to us mere mortals; and of course congratulate Holmes for being stellar in his acute observation and deduction. This and Watson’s humanising influence, in my opinion, are his primary roles in the detective story’s many television and film incarnations.

    Freeman’s Watson possesses just the right balance of innocence and doubt to being a surrogate for the puzzled watcher. When the complicated plot has been carefully explained near episode’s end, Holmes’ “It’s elementary, my dear Watson” could have been meant not just to his [investigating] partner in solving crime but to us all.

    The speculative homoeroticisation in the interplay between Holmes and Watson in the three part BBC miniseries is somewhat understandable, having been fuelled by the writers obliging Holmes to say at some point , “John, I think you should know I consider myself married to my work and while I am flattered by your interest, I am really not looking for anyone.” If Batman and Robin are viewed as precedents, their superhero hood has weathered well and not been in the least diminished by the same sexual speculation

Comments are closed.