While The Great Gatsby looks great many reviewers found it lacked real depth.
New York Times The Great Gatsby review
The best way to enjoy Baz Luhrmann’s big and noisy new version of The Great Gatsby — and despite what you may have heard, it is an eminently enjoyable movie — is to put aside whatever literary agenda you are tempted to bring with you. I grant that this is not so easily done. F Scott Fitzgerald’s slender, charming third novel has accumulated a heavier burden of cultural significance than it can easily bear.
[Rating: 5 star] From our reading of the review
US Today The Great Gatsby review
The director has fashioned a gaudy long-form music video — all kaleidoscopic spectacle and little substance — rather than a radiant new take on an American literary classic. F Scott Fitzgerald’s epic tragedy is lost amid the lavish excess.
[Rating: 2.5 star] From our reading of the review
The Washington Post The Great Gatsby review
The net effect is akin to seeing The Great Gatsby miniaturized, its characters carefully choreographed against storybook illustrations of overworked perfection. It’s glib to suggest that Luhrmann has made a Great Gatsby for idiots; it’s more like he’s made it for infants, who prefer their nourishment pre-masticated and their stories pictorialized by way of bright, arresting images.
[Rating: 2 star] From our reading of the review
Entertainment Weekly The Great Gatsby review
DiCaprio has a smooth, sun-kissed charisma as Gatsby, calling Nick ”old sport” in a clubby drawl. But it’s Edgerton, as the boisterous bully Tom, who commands the audience’s attention. Behind his Douglas Fairbanks pencil mustache and backslapping Ivy League hauteur lies the film’s most nuanced performance.
[Rating: 4 star]
Our overall view based on these reviews is: [Rating: 3.5 star].